surface: chatgpt-openai
query: best personal injury lawyer in New York
status: LIVE
captured: 2026-06-07
sponsored_observed: Several Brands, LLC (labeled "Sponsored" — "Exclusive Auto Accident Leads, Qualified auto accident leads for injury firms"). A lead-generation advertiser, not a law firm; not named in the organic list.
location: New York (city pinned; single-location reading, not national)
---
ChatGPT answer to "best personal injury lawyer in New York" — "Top New York Personal Injury Lawyers & Firms" (with Forbes / Law Leaderboard citations + a local map):

1. The Law Office of Richard M. Kenny — strong client reviews, accident/injury litigation.
2. Shulman & Hill (Manhattan) — large NYC injury practice, workplace + vehicle accidents.
3. Anthony H. Gair of Gair, Gair, Conason, Rubinowitz, Bloom, Hershenhorn, Steigman & Mackauf — "one of New York's premier trial lawyers."
4. Ben B. Rubinowitz (also Gair Gair Conason) — elite plaintiff trial attorney, catastrophic injury + med-mal.
5. Stephen J. Murphy of Block O'Toole & Murphy — large verdicts, serious injury + construction.
6. Frank V. Floriani of Sullivan Papain Block McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo — product liability, med-mal.

Firms named: Richard M. Kenny, Shulman & Hill, Gair Gair Conason, Block O'Toole & Murphy, Sullivan Papain.

Tracked-brand presence: Richard M. Kenny CITED rank 1; Shulman and Hill CITED rank 2; Gair Gair Conason CITED rank 3; Block O'Toole CITED rank 5; Sullivan Papain CITED rank 6; Perecman ABSENT; Eric Richman ABSENT; Hecht Kleeger ABSENT; Fellows Hymowitz ABSENT.

SPONSORED: Several Brands, LLC held the labeled "Sponsored" slot (auto-accident lead generation). It is not a law firm and was not named in the organic list.

NOTE: Gair Gair Conason and Block O'Toole & Murphy appear on BOTH ChatGPT and Gemini for this query, real cross-surface consensus (unlike the agency category, which had none). Confirms NYC personal-injury law is a coherent, consensus-prone local cluster.